free hit counter
An unofficial blog from the creators of www.whoateallthepies.tv
Arsenal Pies

Is it time to introduce Hawk-Eye technology to football?


Last week’s games against Steaua Bucharest in the Champions League saw Arsene Wenger wading into the video technology debate, after a Gael Clichy deflected cross looked as though it crossed the goal-line.

Le Boss was upset that the referee did not award a goal when keeper Robinson Zapata seemed to carry the ball into his own net, but Wenger acknowledged it was touch and go and advocated the use of technology to sort out such dilemmas.

"I did not see whether it crossed,” he said after the game. “ITV said no, Romanian TV said yes. I thought it would have been the other way round. It's one more call for goal-line technology."

Certainly such technology would help to take some pressure off the match officials, but I believe once it is introduced in one part of the game, it could quickly spread to other situations and that might lead us to a very stop-start game. And I’m sure we don’t want to see football transformed into a staccato sport along the lines of American football.

However, the voices backing such video-based technology are growing louder and it now appears that UEFA president Michel Platini (pictured) is on board and could be thinking about sanctioning the use of a Hawk-Eye-style system, as is used in tennis, to end disputes about the ball crossing the goal-line...

"Football must remain human, but we must also try to limit mistakes," said Platini. However, he stressed he remains “totally opposed” to instant video replays, meaning that any video technology would be used purely for goal-line decisions.

I have to say I go along with Platini on this point. Part of the joy of football is that games generate talking points that we can all argue about in the playground or pub or at work with our mates. The over-use of video technology would not only slow the game down, but would also eliminate most of those talking points. Good Lord, that might even lead to the sad day when the crowd would start appreciating the referee.

The introduction of a Hawk-Eye system would need to be backed by the International Football Associations Board, the body that governs the laws of the game. But the good news for any techies out there is that during its last annual general meeting in March, the IFAB drew up guidelines on experiments involving goal-line technology.

As a result, any proposed system would only be able to apply to goal-line technology, in line with Platini’s wishes. The system must be 100% accurate, instantaneous, and only communicable to the match officials.

On the last criteria, I don’t know how the IFAB could prevent TV companies from using the same technology in live match broadcasts, but I guess the point is that fans inside the ground would not be allowed to see any replays when the system is called into use. That would be a shame, because in tennis the Hawk-Eye system has become a firm favourite of the fans already and has added to the entertainment element in the sport.

What do you think? Is the time right to introduce computer technology to assist match officials? And should UEFA be looking to use such systems for offsides, handballs and fouls? Or would the introduction of such systems harm the beautiful game? Share your thoughts using our comments section below

Came straight to this page? Visit www.arsenalpies.tv for all the latest news.

If you’ve enjoyed feasting on Arsenal Pies then you’ll love whoateallthepies.tv, the best source of football news, views and gossip in the blogosphere!

Posted by Gordon Masson on October 9, 2007 1:00 PM in Debate of the Day| News
| Comments (1) | digg this | del.icio.us this | Stumble It!

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://shinymedia.headshift.com/cgi-bin/mtshiny/mt-tb.fcgi/61007

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Is it time to introduce Hawk-Eye technology to football?:

Comments

I understand there will be a goal-line technology trial held in a lower division (possibly non-league) in England before the end of the season.

It won't be holding my breath for it to be ratified by the IFAB though as FIFA have traditionally shown a reluctance to bring in technology to the sport.

I wonder if Adidas were sponsoring it maybe they would give it their backing - like the disastrous smartball experiment of 2005.

Who controls the system though, the home club would have some control as the technology would be installed in their stadium - would this be open to manipulation ?

Posted by: Sport Blogger | October 9, 2007 3:32 PM

Post a comment







Shiny Latest

Shiny Tech Shiny Fashion Shiny Lifestyle Shiny Sport Shiny Games
Subscribe to my feed, Tech Digest Tech Digest
  1. Sony updates BWU-200S PC Blu-ray burner SHOCKER!
  2. The Dreamcade 2.0 Cocktail arcade machine will send you back to the '80s
  3. eBay overpaid for Skype (says Skype founder as he's flying his personal jet)
  4. Korea/Japan Week: Contrary to popular belief, the Japanese Agriculture Ministry is not in charge of Gundam :(
Subscribe to my feed, Catwalk Queen  Catwalk Queen
  1. Amy Winehouse hangs out with the Olsens at the launch of The Row
  2. Frock Horror of the Week: Victoria Beckham's feathered fright
  3. Anthropologie Chamonix cardigan jacket
  4. Trend Alert: Grandpa-style cardigans
Subscribe to my feed, Hippyshopper  Hippyshopper
  1. A green night out in the big apple
  2. 2007 Green Awards: Shortlist announced
  3. Controversial plans to build 'eco homes' on Metropolitan Green Belt revealed
  4. WIN a bumper beauty pack from new natural beauty site How On Earth!
Subscribe to my feed, Who Ate All The Pies Who ate all the Pies
  1. Do LA Galaxy need David Beckham back?
  2. Shit Lookalike: Nicolas Anelka and the Hindu goddess Kali
  3. THE VOTE Who should partner Steven Gerrard in England's midfield?
  4. Oranje Wednesday: Heerenveen stick nine past Heracles, Feyenoord go top
Subscribe to my feed, PSPSPS  PSPSPS
  1. Football Manager 2008 trailer
  2. Capcom pull Monster Hunter 3 for PS3
  3. Orangey Box of goodness!
  4. Medal Of Honor: Airborne video review
Subscribe to my feed, Shiny Shiny Shiny Shiny
  1. Rolex to partner with LG on their next collaboration phone?
  2. Wave goodbye to trick-or-treaters with the LED Voodo Skull
  3. The Zippo hand-warmer comes along just in time for the cold(ish) weather
  4. Shiny Poll: How much would you voluntarily pay for an album?
Subscribe to my feed, Shoewawa  Shoewawa
  1. Betsey Johnson's brown 'Warwick' peep toes with pink lining and gold ankle-strap
  2. Purple patent platform shoes from French Connection
  3. New Mary Janes at Accessorize are fantastic in fuschia!
  4. Yay or Nay Wednesday
Subscribe to my feed, Corrie Blog  Corrie Blog
  1. Corrie Sneak Previews, October 14 - 19
  2. Police overwhelmed during Corrie ad breaks
  3. Bruno Langley - "I've grown up - and so has Todd"
  4. Corrie's Sean and Violet in custody battle
Subscribe to my feed, Chelsea Pies  Chelsea Pies
  1. National gaffers obsessed with Chelsea 3: Jurgen Klinsmann reveals how Roman Abramovich was the big turn off at Chelsea
  2. Ronald Koeman claims Henk ten Cate is nothing more than a Dutch Brian Kidd. Everybody panic!
  3. Poll of the day: what would you do if you were Steve Clarke now?
  4. Is the Leicester Carling cup tie doomed to have another embarassing attendance like Rosenborg?
Subscribe to my feed, XBoxer  XBoxer
  1. New Xbox 360 chipset, codenamed 'Jasper' on the way?
  2. Life size Big Daddy on 'teh eBay'
  3. Medal Of Honor: Airborne video review
  4. Free Radical officially announces TimeSplitters IV
Subscribe to my feed, Techscape  Techscape
  1. ShoZu to support geotagging for Flickr, YouTube and others
  2. 3GSM 2007: Clicmobile on why mobile social networking is going niche
  3. 3 finally brings social networking into X-Series
  4. Nokia to enter mobile advertising market with Nokia Ad Service
Subscribe to my feed, Kiss and Makeup  Kiss and Makeup
  1. WIN a bumper beauty pack from new natural beauty site How On Earth!
  2. Review: Clinique Airbrush Concealer
  3. Find your wallet and get thee self to Boots, there's new things at Soap and Glory!
  4. Tissues at the ready, say bye bye to Pout
Subscribe to my feed, Available For Panto  Available for Panto
  1. Strictly Come Dancing: the girls' group dance
  2. Osbournes to have huge auction
  3. Daily Poll: Has the BBC made a big mistake?
  4. Strictly Come Dancing: Brendan Cole's a big flirt
Subscribe to my feed, ManunitedPies  Man United Pies
  1. Cristiano Ronaldo, Wayne Rooney and Carlos Tevez make shortlist for FIFA World Player of the Year
  2. Darrron Gibson sent out to learn his trade at Wolves
  3. Editor's opinion: Old rivalries renewed again with Arsenal but are they so bitter?
  4. Ben Foster optimistic for the future
Subscribe to my feed, Wii Wii  Wii Wii
  1. test
  2. Why Nintendo should buy Twitter to integrate with Wii
  3. On the Virtual Console today:
  4. WiiWare: Original downloadable games on Wii
Subscribe to my feed, HDTV UK  HDTV UK
  1. Toshiba to bundle HD DVD demo disc with A205 laptop
  2. Acer offers dual format HD drive in M5630 PC
  3. Virgin Media to offer Voom HD via 50Mbps broadband service
  4. NBC to broadcast single HD?SD feed for 2008 Olympics
Subscribe to my feed, The Bag Lady  The Bag Lady
  1. Blue leather pocket Shopper from Topshop
  2. Samantha Cameron 'Nancy' bag for Smythson sells out and causes controversy
  3. The return of the Fendi baguette in time for the release of SATC movie
  4. Enfant Terrible earrings
Subscribe to my feed, Crafty Crafty  Crafty Crafty
  1. How to: Make fantastic felted pumpkins for Halloween
  2. The amazing 'Uno' crochet dress
  3. Recycled cardboard 'Chiquita' chandelier
  4. Free Crafty Crafty Pattern: Jolly Roger skull and crossbone potholder or placemat
Subscribe to my feed, Liverpool Pies  Liverpool Pies
  1. Who remembers...? #1: Rob Jones
  2. Can it be true? Could Harry Kewell really be fit for the Everton match?
  3. Steven Gerrard 40/1 odds for FIFA Player of the Year Award
  4. Has Liverpool Pies done something really bad?
Subscribe to my feed, Games Digest  Game Digest
  1. Sony updates BWU-200S PC Blu-ray burner SHOCKER!
  2. The Dreamcade 2.0 Cocktail arcade machine will send you back to the '80s
  3. eBay overpaid for Skype (says Skype founder as he's flying his personal jet)
  4. Korea/Japan Week: Contrary to popular belief, the Japanese Agriculture Ministry is not in charge of Gundam :(
Subscribe to my feed, iPhonic  iPhonic
  1. Apple limting users to eight iPhone ringtones?
  2. Switzerland, France, UK's Carphone Warehouse: international iPhone update
  3. Pyrofer turns iPhone into 3.5G-capable browser
  4. iPhone firmware 1.1.1 hacked
Subscribe to my feed, Bridalwave  Bridalwave
  1. Martha Stewart's Cheerful Cherries favours
  2. Golf ball wedding favours
  3. Cufflinks for the best man from John Lewis
  4. Photo brownie wedding favours - eat your own image!
Subscribe to my feed, LostWeekend  Lost Weekend
  1. Zagat’s Rundown of New York Restaurants Cements Gordon F*****g Ramsay’s Comeback
  2. Australian Fans Hold Rugby World Cup Semi-Final Tickets to Ransom
  3. Zimbabwean Government Fails at Democracy So Has a Go at Tourism
  4. Guidebook Lauds Great-Gastronomical-British Cuisine
Subscribe to my feed, SpursPies  Spurs Pies
  1. Spurs' UEFA Cup opponents: The Lowdown
  2. Caption Comp: What's Jermain Defoe and John Terry up to?
  3. Nice work if you can get it, eh Les Ferdinand?
  4. Is Chris Hughton the only Tottenham man who talks sense?
UK Resistence
  1. Sony updates BWU-200S PC Blu-ray burner SHOCKER!
  2. The Dreamcade 2.0 Cocktail arcade machine will send you back to the '80s
  3. eBay overpaid for Skype (says Skype founder as he's flying his personal jet)
  4. Korea/Japan Week: Contrary to popular belief, the Japanese Agriculture Ministry is not in charge of Gundam :(